How strange it must be to get into Metallica via Load / Reload or St. Anger and go to see them live. You'd barely know any of the songs.

Setlist from Super Bock Super Rock Festival, Lisbon, Portugal:

Creeping Death
For Whom The Bell Tolls
Ride The Lightning
Disposable Heroes
Kirk Doodle
The Unforgiven
And Justice for All
The Memory Remains
The Four Horsemen
Rob Doodle
Orion
Fade to Black
Master Of Puppets
Battery
Sad But True
Nothing Else Matters
One
Enter Sandman
Am I Evil?
Seek and Destroy

Available for purchase as MP3 or FLAC (lossless) at livemetallica.com a service I can't praise the band enough for.